Friday, June 3, 2011

Dewey-Chapter 16 - Some general conclusion

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 16 - Some general conclusion

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 15 - The recitation and the training of thought

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 14 - Observation and information in the training of mind

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 13 - Language and the training of thought

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 12 - Activity and the training of thought

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 11 - Empirical and Scientific Thinking

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 10 - Concrete & Abstract Thinking

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 9 - Meaning: or conception and understanding

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 8 - Judgement-The interpretation of facts

Thoughts?

Dewey Chapter 7 - Systematic Inference

Thoughts?

Dewey-Chapter 6 - Analysis of a complete act of thought

Thoughts?

Dewey Chapter 5 - The Means and End of Mental Training

Hello Colleagues,

So Dewey has provided for me a new understanding of 'logical' when compared to my scientific background: that of a "sytematic care....taken to safeguard reflection so that it may yield the best results under the given conditions....wide awake, thorough and careful reflection..." (pp. 56-57). Once again Dewey has demonstrated that the quality of any idea can only be measured by the usefulness of the end-product. It would appear to me that for Dewey, logistics is not only a 'careful process', but also rather that which must yield in people a productive 'habit of mind'. With this revised definition, I can appreciate why Dewey would see logical thinking as the main product of education for our students.

Dewey's dialectic on formal vs. informal learning, psychological vs. logical, discipline vs. freedom were all familiar but  very enlightening in the way that they were presented in this chapter. I see them now as being a part of modern theory on the dangers of 'rote learning' and the advantages of 'inquiry learning', and what we call 'playful discovery' in science. Dewey makes a clear case as to the advantageous of both ideologies, while warning of the dangers of total reliance on either. Perhaps my favorite quote from this chapter is "Any teacher who is alive to the modes of though naturally operatie in the experience of the normal child will have no difficulty in avoiding the identification of subject-matter, as well as the notion that the only way to escape this erroris to pay no attention to logical considerations" (p.62).

My question from Dewey's discourse in this chapter surrounds the ideas of practicing the art of  'checking or controlling impulse' as a part of developing reflection (p.64). Some might argue that had many inventors and scientist checked their impulse or hunch to do something, certain great discoveries might never have beene made. I'm wondering if we follow Dewey's logic of developing habits of mind that yield reflective thinking might be stunting to human ingenuity. Thalia.

Wednesday, June 1, 2011

Dewey Chapter 4 - School Conditions and the training of Thought

Hello Colleagues,

It is interesting to note that Dewey, after recognizing the multiple ways that different school subjects can be intellectual, he identifies a dichotomy that has been a major impediment in the act of teaching:- what one plans for teaching (mental training) vs. what one actually does, consciously or unconsciously (p. 46). It reminded of the famous saying, "do as I say and not as I do". I was moved with Dewey's postulate that teachers who are intellegient students of both of these aspects of teaching, as well as the effects of school conditions can be "largely trusted to develop for himself methods of instruction....best adapted to achieve results" (p.46).  I immediately thought of recent shifts towards high stakes testing and grading of schools based on these results, and wondered if this is because of the lack of understanding at government, community and school levels such that there is skepticism in our teachers ability to develop their own methods of instruction best adapted to achieve results? Are the teacher education programs providing sufficient attention to the kinds of mental training and reflective thought that prepare teaches to be developers of their own instructions?

I really liked Dewey's expose on how teachers mental predispostion can have profound effect on what student focused on in school, and that the teacher predisposition can form habitual behaviours in student. I though of many of my 'quirky' teachers to this could really apply....where the kind of answers you give and the way that you respond to the subject is really tied much to their personality, rather than the inherent values in the subject.  I wonder though, that as long as 'human teachers' are involved in the process of education, will we ever be able to overcome this phenomena in education.

In connection with chapter 3, Dewey reminds again during his discourse of knowledge vs. wisdom, of the importance of linking teaching with real world situations. He convincingly notes, "the assumption that information which has been accumulated apart from use in the recognition and solution of a problem may later on be freely employed at will by thought is false." This reminded of another wise saying, 'practice makes perfect' - which is why Dewey contended that people with little book learning but much experience are very productive and useful. I think schools are beginning to recognize this more and more, not only teaching but more practical and authentic assessments.  I couldn't help adding a piece of biblical writing to Dewey's discourse on wisdom from the book of Proverbs 4:4, "Wisdom is the principal thing; therefore get wisdom:and with all thy getting get understanding". As much as wisdom is glorified, as Dewey puts it. it is ..."the operation of knowledge"; I still believe that having a heart of understanding...knowing when to apply wisdom....when something seems the 'wisest' thing to do...understanding may say 'the time is not yet right...there are other extenuating circumstances etc. etc., , which is what makes us humane and not 'wise machines'. Thalia.

Monday, May 30, 2011

Dewey Chapter 3 - Natural Resources in the training of Thought

Hello Colleagues,

It was interesting to see how Dewey's ideas in this chapter are such a a concrete part of educational theory and practice today!
1. Understanding children's stages of development originating with curiosity (Piaget)
2. How all children, barring physical defects, have the capacity to learn
3. every child may need different amounts of time and ways to learn
4. That all subjects have the capacity to serve as intellectual stimulation ...whether, cooking or geometery or music ( early underpinnings of Muliple Intelligiences)

I was particularly taken with Dewey's notions that the best mental habit is finding a balance between "paucity and redundancy of suggestions" (p. 36)  (that is how I feel sometimes in this program where we are being exposed to so much...so quickly....:), but is also a serious consideration for the application of educational theory into practice. In our classrooms with our students, and even on a larger scale in our educational communities, we do not want important actions to be "paralyzed by the multiplicity of views'. I believe this is one of the greates challenges to education today...we are trying to expose our students to so much, it ends up paralyzing them from acting as simple human beings. Also, there are so many opinions on what is best for education, more time is spent fighting about who is correct than actually doing something about our educational woes.

Which leads me to my second thought....I certainly agree with Dewey's conclusion that we need to stop the osscillation between the extremes of neglecting educative activities (i.e. those that prepare students for real life) because they can be so transitory in nature, or overfocusing on them (with a belief that they will solve the issues of mental training).  I only wish here, that Dewey had given us some practical examples of his day so that we could have more closely followed his line of thought and build on it.  I agree that we need to find the "best adapted for the students stage of development", the ones that have the most "ulterior promise" for preparation for adult life and as Dewey emphasized "at the same time "having maximum influence in forming habit of observation and consecutive inferencing. (p. 44). This reminded me of our EDLT class and the text, Always On by Baron in our recent literacy course.  In relation to this, the example I thought of to fill Dewey's gap here, is how students can best integrate their use of modern technology in the classrooms, with habits that will develop their reflective thinking while preparing them for life in the real world.  Thalia.

Dewey- Chapter 2-The need for training Thought

Hello Colleagues,

Dewey makes a clear case for thought as a natural part of 'civilized' human activity. His examples of  deliberate, "making of signs in advance of wreckage" and "erecting monuments and memorials lest we forget" (p.66), supports his argument.  His further references to the works of Venn, Mill, Locke and Bacon all concretely and definitively point to the 'power and rulership' of thought in the civilized life, and more importantly, how thought development or training can be wrecked by mental laziness, lacking sufficient exposure (wider knowledge) and succumbing to our passions and dominant authority.  I also had a proclivity for his discourse on inferencing as the 'exercising of thought'. Inferencing is a skill we often use in science education. At the end of practicals, we would usually ask students, "so what can you infer from your results?"...in other words, I was really saying...exercise thought about what happened...neat!

I have two questions from this chapter. The first surrounds notions of 'savage' vs. the 'civilized'.  I'm still grappling with some of the terms Dewey uses like 'brute' and 'idiot' as describing those who may not have advanced to the level of reflective thinking and who may continue to function on 'instinctive' levels. Could it be that such individuals, as they are in their spheres of operations, daily life and discourses, have thoughts that serve to  allow them to compete and survive adequately in their environs? Albeit, they might be more vulnerable to the elements of nature, or the domination of others, who can decide what their purposes or destinies could, should and can be....such that we determine that their thoughts are inadequate in some way.

The second relates to what Dewey contends to be the 'business of education', - to "cultivate deep-seated and effective habits of discriminating tested beliefs from mere assertions...."etc. (p. 28). He postulates that without these habits, one is not "intellectual" and requires "training of the mind". This reminded me again of what we term in my field necessary 'scientific attitudes' of being skeptical, avoiding broad generalizations and refusal to believe in superstition' (Teaching Science for All Children, Martin et al, 2010). Dewey's 'business of education' is often in contention with students decisions to have faith and belief in God, their religion and that which cannot be tested and proven.  As a person of faith myself, I wondered if Dewey factored in his 'effective habits', that of 'open-mindedness' to allow students to choose to believe in whatever they desire and has 'proven' to be effective in their lives. Many students are in families that have experience divine healing etc., which cannot be proven scientifically, and I can see where they could easily be classified as non-intellectual, but really have quite effective habits of reflective thinking. Thalia

Thursday, May 26, 2011

Dewey Chapt 1 - What is thought?

Hello Colleagues,

Who would have ever thought there was so much to say about thoughts? Following Dewey's musings on thought were quite simple, yet complex....more so because of his method of exposition rather than complexity of ideas. Quite simply he contends that there are two levels of thoughts...that which simply passes through the head vs. reflective thought, i.e., that which results from conscious effort to support or refute beliefs. I like the simple examples he uses to show the dichotomy, like when one decides it's going to rain, and Columbus' thoughts of a round instead of a flat world. I also agree that there needs to be a certain amount of 'troubling' for reflective thinking - as Dewey puts it, to overcome "the inertia that inclined one to accept suggestions at their face value" (p. 13).  This reminded me of Piaget's theories of mental disequilibrium, a postulate that the human mind cannot withstand cognitive dissonance (exposure to new information)  and will either accomodate new information ( simply file away if it is unrelated to existing schema) or assimilate ( new information will fit into existing schema).
(Incidentally, in my field of science education, this is a critical component of Constructivism -  the dominant theory now for science learning )

My questions from this first chapter surrounds the notions of Dewey's thought about the scope and value of reflective thinking. He notes that the training of good mental habits is "acquiring the attitude of suspended conclusion..." and "...maintaining the state of doubt..." (p.13) as essentials of thinking.  As mentioned above, it would appear that the human mind is very much against maintenance of doubt and suspension. It (the mind) always seems to seek what Piaget called cognitive dissonance, or what I would like to call rest.  In light of this then, I wondered, why would anyone want to "endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance" (p.13)? I would certainly agree that when we approach our studies, or the many vissisitudes of life, we can benefit from the mental habit of 'suspending conclusion making', but I do feel that there are times in our lives that we do not wish our thinking to be troubled...we simply want to allow our minds to wander for the joy of thinking...wherever that wandering leads us. Or we may simply choose to believe based on our faith in what we cannot see or every prove by protracted inquiry. Is that to say then that at those times, we are not thinking reflectively? If we do not approach suggestions with doubt or "carry on systematic and protracted inquiry..." (p. 13), can it be concluded that one may not be thinking reflectively?

From my own experiences, when our courses are over, I have many continued reflective thoughts about what we covered...however I am exhausted, my mind is tired and I do not wish it to be troubled any further, nor do I approach those thoughts systematically or protractedly...rather, I allow my mind to wander freely on other 'possibilities' and 'potentials'. I haven't begun to read the other chapters yet, but I am hoping that I would find recognition of preambles for reflective thinking  beyond 'doubt' and 'protracted systematic inquiry' but to also include 'potential and possibilities', as having power to foster reflective thinking too. Thalia.