Hello Colleagues,
So Dewey has provided for me a new understanding of 'logical' when compared to my scientific background: that of a "sytematic care....taken to safeguard reflection so that it may yield the best results under the given conditions....wide awake, thorough and careful reflection..." (pp. 56-57). Once again Dewey has demonstrated that the quality of any idea can only be measured by the usefulness of the end-product. It would appear to me that for Dewey, logistics is not only a 'careful process', but also rather that which must yield in people a productive 'habit of mind'. With this revised definition, I can appreciate why Dewey would see logical thinking as the main product of education for our students.
Dewey's dialectic on formal vs. informal learning, psychological vs. logical, discipline vs. freedom were all familiar but very enlightening in the way that they were presented in this chapter. I see them now as being a part of modern theory on the dangers of 'rote learning' and the advantages of 'inquiry learning', and what we call 'playful discovery' in science. Dewey makes a clear case as to the advantageous of both ideologies, while warning of the dangers of total reliance on either. Perhaps my favorite quote from this chapter is "Any teacher who is alive to the modes of though naturally operatie in the experience of the normal child will have no difficulty in avoiding the identification of subject-matter, as well as the notion that the only way to escape this erroris to pay no attention to logical considerations" (p.62).
My question from Dewey's discourse in this chapter surrounds the ideas of practicing the art of 'checking or controlling impulse' as a part of developing reflection (p.64). Some might argue that had many inventors and scientist checked their impulse or hunch to do something, certain great discoveries might never have beene made. I'm wondering if we follow Dewey's logic of developing habits of mind that yield reflective thinking might be stunting to human ingenuity. Thalia.
The entire time I was reading the chapter I kept thinking about the lack of consideration to the developmental stages in schools today. Dewey stated “At present, the notion is current that childhood is almost entirely unreflective—a period of mere sensory, motor, and memory development, while adolescence suddenly brings the manifestation of though and reason” (p. 63). I laughed at the disclaimer on adolescent skill level. I am not sure I totally agree with this because I have taught many students who demonstrated the ability to reflect very early on in elementary school.
ReplyDeleteThalia, your statement ‘playful discovery’ in science really defines a developmentally appropriate method to blending “natural and psychological activities, even when not consciously controlled by logical considerations” (p. 62). Early childhood specialist, really understand this methodology. I found my favorite concept by Dewey as “intellectual education is the transformation of natural powers into expert, tested powers: the transformation of more or less casual curiosity and sporadic suggestion into attitudes of alert, cautious and thorough inquiry” (p. 62) to be aligned with my own teaching philosophy. As a first and second grade teacher I utilized the concept of expert to intrinsically motivate my students to become mini experts in whatever we were studying. This really enhanced student engagement.