Hello Colleagues,
Who would have ever thought there was so much to say about thoughts? Following Dewey's musings on thought were quite simple, yet complex....more so because of his method of exposition rather than complexity of ideas. Quite simply he contends that there are two levels of thoughts...that which simply passes through the head vs. reflective thought, i.e., that which results from conscious effort to support or refute beliefs. I like the simple examples he uses to show the dichotomy, like when one decides it's going to rain, and Columbus' thoughts of a round instead of a flat world. I also agree that there needs to be a certain amount of 'troubling' for reflective thinking - as Dewey puts it, to overcome "the inertia that inclined one to accept suggestions at their face value" (p. 13). This reminded me of Piaget's theories of mental disequilibrium, a postulate that the human mind cannot withstand cognitive dissonance (exposure to new information) and will either accomodate new information ( simply file away if it is unrelated to existing schema) or assimilate ( new information will fit into existing schema).
(Incidentally, in my field of science education, this is a critical component of Constructivism - the dominant theory now for science learning )
My questions from this first chapter surrounds the notions of Dewey's thought about the scope and value of reflective thinking. He notes that the training of good mental habits is "acquiring the attitude of suspended conclusion..." and "...maintaining the state of doubt..." (p.13) as essentials of thinking. As mentioned above, it would appear that the human mind is very much against maintenance of doubt and suspension. It (the mind) always seems to seek what Piaget called cognitive dissonance, or what I would like to call rest. In light of this then, I wondered, why would anyone want to "endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance" (p.13)? I would certainly agree that when we approach our studies, or the many vissisitudes of life, we can benefit from the mental habit of 'suspending conclusion making', but I do feel that there are times in our lives that we do not wish our thinking to be troubled...we simply want to allow our minds to wander for the joy of thinking...wherever that wandering leads us. Or we may simply choose to believe based on our faith in what we cannot see or every prove by protracted inquiry. Is that to say then that at those times, we are not thinking reflectively? If we do not approach suggestions with doubt or "carry on systematic and protracted inquiry..." (p. 13), can it be concluded that one may not be thinking reflectively?
From my own experiences, when our courses are over, I have many continued reflective thoughts about what we covered...however I am exhausted, my mind is tired and I do not wish it to be troubled any further, nor do I approach those thoughts systematically or protractedly...rather, I allow my mind to wander freely on other 'possibilities' and 'potentials'. I haven't begun to read the other chapters yet, but I am hoping that I would find recognition of preambles for reflective thinking beyond 'doubt' and 'protracted systematic inquiry' but to also include 'potential and possibilities', as having power to foster reflective thinking too. Thalia.
Thalia,
ReplyDeleteYour post followed my thought process as I read the first chapter. I haven’t ever really thought about what the difference is between reflection and thinking. Dewey stated, “Reflection involves not simply a sequence of ideas, but a consequence—a consecutive ordering in such a way that each determines the next as its proper outcome, while each in turn leans on its predecessors” (pg. 2-3). This statement made me think of prior knowledge and relevant experiences used to gain understanding of content.
I found the section referencing prejudices, and strong passion misguiding judgments due to the lack of adequate survey of evidence (pg. 5) to correlate to Valencia’s, “deficit thinking” and how we as educators don’t have the energy or the courage to question, and our teaching is based on what Dewey referred to as “imaginative thought, plastic to our mood” (pg. 5).
A personal articulation of the difference between reflection and thinking began to formulate in my mind. Reflection requires applied knowledge combined with evidence to support conclusions. Thinking requires the examination of evidence applied to one’s imagination or “irresponsible stream of fancies” (pg. 6). As I read I began to think about how challenging it is to teach students to infer about literature. We as educators are asking students to multi-task by reflecting and thinking at the same time. This can be very difficult for students that don’t have relevant experience to reference for a better understanding of content. In the field of science the process is enhanced through exploration. The real challenge comes from teaching difficult literature for example; many students have difficulty relating to content due to the lack of life experiences. This form of regulation of thinking by its purpose can be challenging.
Dewey stated, “Reflective thinking is always more or less troublesome because it involves overcoming the inertia that inclines one to accept suggestions at their face value; it involves willingness to endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance” (p.13).
I too, thought of the spring semester and the “willingness to endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance” which clearly defines how I felt all semester. I personally need to allow my brain to rest in order to sleep. I enjoy letting my mind wonder without purpose for my own mental rest and peace.
Thalia,
ReplyDeleteYour post followed my thought process as I read the first chapter. I haven’t ever really thought about what the difference is between reflection and thinking. Dewey stated, “Reflection involves not simply a sequence of ideas, but a consequence—a consecutive ordering in such a way that each determines the next as its proper outcome, while each in turn leans on its predecessors” (pg. 2-3). This statement made me think of prior knowledge and relevant experiences used to gain understanding of content.
I found the section referencing prejudices, and strong passion misguiding judgments due to the lack of adequate survey of evidence (pg. 5) to correlate to Valencia’s, “deficit thinking” and how we as educators don’t have the energy or the courage to question, and our teaching is based on what Dewey referred to as “imaginative thought, plastic to our mood” (pg. 5).
A personal articulation of the difference between reflection and thinking began to formulate in my mind. Reflection requires applied knowledge combined with evidence to support conclusions. Thinking requires the examination of evidence applied to one’s imagination or “irresponsible stream of fancies” (pg. 6). As I read I began to think about how challenging it is to teach students to infer about literature. We as educators are asking students to multi-task by reflecting and thinking at the same time. This can be very difficult for students that don’t have relevant experience to reference for a better understanding of content. In the field of science the process is enhanced through exploration. The real challenge comes from teaching difficult literature for example; many students have difficulty relating to content due to the lack of life experiences. This form of regulation of thinking by its purpose can be challenging. Dewey stated, “Reflective thinking is always more or less troublesome because it involves overcoming the inertia that inclines one to accept suggestions at their face value; it involves willingness to endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance” (p.13).
I too, thought of the spring semester and the “willingness to endure a condition of mental unrest and disturbance” which clearly defines how I felt all semester. I personally need to allow my brain to rest in order to sleep. I enjoy letting my mind wonder without purpose for my own mental rest and peace.
Hi Kim,
ReplyDeleteI certainly agree with your synopsis of the challenges faced when student do not have the requisite prior knowledge required for reflective thinking. This has huge implications for education. What I am encouraged by, and it comes out in his later chapters, is that we need to start wherever the student are at, and realize that we can use what interest them to help them to develop the 'habits' required for reflective thinking. Thalia