Hello Colleagues,
Dewey makes a clear case for thought as a natural part of 'civilized' human activity. His examples of deliberate, "making of signs in advance of wreckage" and "erecting monuments and memorials lest we forget" (p.66), supports his argument. His further references to the works of Venn, Mill, Locke and Bacon all concretely and definitively point to the 'power and rulership' of thought in the civilized life, and more importantly, how thought development or training can be wrecked by mental laziness, lacking sufficient exposure (wider knowledge) and succumbing to our passions and dominant authority. I also had a proclivity for his discourse on inferencing as the 'exercising of thought'. Inferencing is a skill we often use in science education. At the end of practicals, we would usually ask students, "so what can you infer from your results?"...in other words, I was really saying...exercise thought about what happened...neat!
I have two questions from this chapter. The first surrounds notions of 'savage' vs. the 'civilized'. I'm still grappling with some of the terms Dewey uses like 'brute' and 'idiot' as describing those who may not have advanced to the level of reflective thinking and who may continue to function on 'instinctive' levels. Could it be that such individuals, as they are in their spheres of operations, daily life and discourses, have thoughts that serve to allow them to compete and survive adequately in their environs? Albeit, they might be more vulnerable to the elements of nature, or the domination of others, who can decide what their purposes or destinies could, should and can be....such that we determine that their thoughts are inadequate in some way.
The second relates to what Dewey contends to be the 'business of education', - to "cultivate deep-seated and effective habits of discriminating tested beliefs from mere assertions...."etc. (p. 28). He postulates that without these habits, one is not "intellectual" and requires "training of the mind". This reminded me again of what we term in my field necessary 'scientific attitudes' of being skeptical, avoiding broad generalizations and refusal to believe in superstition' (Teaching Science for All Children, Martin et al, 2010). Dewey's 'business of education' is often in contention with students decisions to have faith and belief in God, their religion and that which cannot be tested and proven. As a person of faith myself, I wondered if Dewey factored in his 'effective habits', that of 'open-mindedness' to allow students to choose to believe in whatever they desire and has 'proven' to be effective in their lives. Many students are in families that have experience divine healing etc., which cannot be proven scientifically, and I can see where they could easily be classified as non-intellectual, but really have quite effective habits of reflective thinking. Thalia
Thalia, I would like to start with the concepts Dewey addressed in his understanding of education. The area that I kept pausing on and contemplating about was the terms used to emphasize the differences between intellectual and what I refer to simple minded or less intellectual. You referenced the following; terms Dewey used like 'brute' and 'idiot' as describing those who may not have advanced to the level of reflective thinking and who may continue to function on 'instinctive' levels. I found those to be harsh and antiquated. I also found myself relating to the area of how quickly a person responds and processes as a sign of intellect and was wondering if the educational system has such a powerful role in conditioning the students’ to process in a manner that requires automaticity in quick responses and less thoughtful responses. I am guilty of this belief and have very rarely found slow to respond people interesting. I will have to rethink some of my own bias in this area and become more patient.
ReplyDeleteAs for the second topic that relates to what Dewey contends to be the 'business of education', - to "cultivate deep-seated and effective habits of discriminating tested beliefs from mere assertions...."etc. (p. 28). He postulates that without these habits, one is not "intellectual" and requires "training of the mind". This reminded me again of what we term in my field necessary 'scientific attitudes' of being skeptical, avoiding broad generalizations and refusal to believe in superstition' (Teaching Science for All Children, Martin et al, 2010). Dewey's 'business of education' is often in contention with students decisions to have faith and belief in God, their religion and that which cannot be tested and proven. Your point about faith and religion resulted my own understanding of many cases where religion and beliefs providing the foundation for individual’s to experience personal reflection that started the training of their minds to contemplate one’s own beliefs. In many cases religion is the one area where people become intellectual. I struggled with Dewey’s clinical concepts and agree with your challenge.
Kim, I enjoyed your reminder of the portion of Dewey that dealt with how we use 'speed of answers' as a measure of intellectual capacity. It reminded of the important strategy of 'effective questioning' called 'wait time'. This strategy suggests that after asking a student a question, we should pause long enough for them to give an answer, and then pause again after their answer to allow them to 'hear themselves' before we respond. Like you, I struggled in this area, and I remember as a novice teacher saying in my mind, after I asked a student a question 'one thousand and one...one thousand and two...one thousand and three..etc. before I rephrased the question if they gave no answer. I still struggle with this today, but I've gotten better, especially as a teacher educator.
ReplyDeleteI'm glad you agreed with my challenge in regards to faith...I like that you saw one's faith as a beginning point for engaging in reflective thought...deep..neat! Thalia.