Hello Colleagues,
It is interesting to note that Dewey, after recognizing the multiple ways that different school subjects can be intellectual, he identifies a dichotomy that has been a major impediment in the act of teaching:- what one plans for teaching (mental training) vs. what one actually does, consciously or unconsciously (p. 46). It reminded of the famous saying, "do as I say and not as I do". I was moved with Dewey's postulate that teachers who are intellegient students of both of these aspects of teaching, as well as the effects of school conditions can be "largely trusted to develop for himself methods of instruction....best adapted to achieve results" (p.46). I immediately thought of recent shifts towards high stakes testing and grading of schools based on these results, and wondered if this is because of the lack of understanding at government, community and school levels such that there is skepticism in our teachers ability to develop their own methods of instruction best adapted to achieve results? Are the teacher education programs providing sufficient attention to the kinds of mental training and reflective thought that prepare teaches to be developers of their own instructions?
I really liked Dewey's expose on how teachers mental predispostion can have profound effect on what student focused on in school, and that the teacher predisposition can form habitual behaviours in student. I though of many of my 'quirky' teachers to this could really apply....where the kind of answers you give and the way that you respond to the subject is really tied much to their personality, rather than the inherent values in the subject. I wonder though, that as long as 'human teachers' are involved in the process of education, will we ever be able to overcome this phenomena in education.
In connection with chapter 3, Dewey reminds again during his discourse of knowledge vs. wisdom, of the importance of linking teaching with real world situations. He convincingly notes, "the assumption that information which has been accumulated apart from use in the recognition and solution of a problem may later on be freely employed at will by thought is false." This reminded of another wise saying, 'practice makes perfect' - which is why Dewey contended that people with little book learning but much experience are very productive and useful. I think schools are beginning to recognize this more and more, not only teaching but more practical and authentic assessments. I couldn't help adding a piece of biblical writing to Dewey's discourse on wisdom from the book of Proverbs 4:4, "Wisdom is the principal thing; therefore get wisdom:and with all thy getting get understanding". As much as wisdom is glorified, as Dewey puts it. it is ..."the operation of knowledge"; I still believe that having a heart of understanding...knowing when to apply wisdom....when something seems the 'wisest' thing to do...understanding may say 'the time is not yet right...there are other extenuating circumstances etc. etc., , which is what makes us humane and not 'wise machines'. Thalia.
Thalia,
ReplyDeleteI found the section on the influence of a teacher's mental habits on the students to be interesting and kept thinking about the article from our literacy class on "Willing to comply" in relation to student adjusting to meet the teacher's requirements. Dewey state the student's desire was driven by "Will this answer or process satisfy the teacher?"-- instead of meaning (p.50).
I was also wondering what you thought about the concept of recitation or memorization undermining the training of the mind? This has been a debate in the schools for the past 10 years. Many teachers feel that automaticity in multiplication facts are a must in order for students to be able to complete the algebraic processes in math. Others feel that students' must understand numbers and computation using many different strategies. According to Dewey it appears that the more wholistic approach is recommended. Dewey stated, "habits of active inquiry and careful deliberation in the significant and vital problems of conduct afford the best guarantee that the general structure of mind will be reasonalble" (p. 55). I used to believe that the process was more important. However, I have found with the rapid pace of edcuation the need for automaticity in math facts is helpful in teaching students algebra.
Hello Kim,
ReplyDeleteYour question is certainly a recursive one in the annals of education! Like you, from my reading, I believe Dewey would have taken a wholistic approach as well, i.e. where he would have seen the need for automaticitiy in maths (I've just been training my daughter on her 6 multiplication...thank God my son has completed up to 12) but also the need to understand 'numbers and computation'. I am so excited when my kids begin to see the connection between division and multiplication, and this ties right into why automaticitiy with multiplication is so important! My son exclaimed..."oh that is why you need to know your tables!" Thalia